What is the role of policy judgments in administrative decision-making, and how are they treated on review?

Policy judgments must be unanimous within the agency to be reviewable.

Policy judgments are given deference if within the statutory framework and supported by a rational basis; arbitrary or irrational policy is reviewable.

Policy judgments are decisions that reflect the agency’s weighings of policy choices within its statutory mandate. Courts don’t second-guess every policy call; they give deference as long as the judgment stays within the statutory framework and is grounded in a rational basis. That means the agency considered relevant factors, followed the statute’s goals, and did not rely on irrational or unsupported reasoning. If the policy choice is arbitrary or irrational, or exceeds the agency’s statutory authority, it can be set aside on review.

So the best answer reflects that balance: deference when the policy decision is within the statute and has a rational basis; but review is available if the policy is arbitrary or irrational.

Policy judgments are always overturned if challenged.

Policy judgments are never reviewed.

Want more questions?

All options are one-time payments.

$25.99

30 day pass for new members

All the basics to get you started

  • Ad-free experience
  • View your previous attempt history
  • Mobile app access
  • In-depth explanations
  • 30 day premium pass access
$59.99$171.99 usd

6 month DELUXE pass (most popular)

Full access FOR 6 MONTHS! & the ultimate digital PDF study guide (BONUS)

  • $171.99 usd value for $59.99! You save $106!
  • Ad-free experience
  • View your previous attempt history
  • Mobile app access
  • In-depth explanations
  • 6 months of full access
  • Ultimate digital PDF study guide included
  • Priority support
$15.99 $24.99

Ultimate digital PDF study guide

For those that prefer a more traditional form of learning

  • Available for instant download
  • Available offline
  • Hundreds of practice multiple choice questions
  • Comprehensive content
  • Detailed explanations
Image Description
Subscribe

Get the latest from Passetra

You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our privacy policy